|
Model |
Example Program or Organization |
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
|
Residential Camp |
Sport & Recreation Camps (Australia)
Summer Camps (USA) |
Cost-efficient; residential; involves
teachers |
Recreational focus; Isolated
experience; Not integrated with curriculum; Requires capital and
established facilities; Limited research evidence |
|
Adventure Expedition-Based |
Outward Bound |
Personal development focus;
residential; involves teachers; research outcomes |
Isolated experience sometimes
integrated with curriculum; moderate expense; Dwindling access to
wilderness areas |
|
Science Expedition-Based |
ANZSES (Australia and New Zealand
Scientific Exploring Society) |
Integrates with curriculum; includes
intellectual challenge |
Limited availability; limited research
evidence |
|
Environmental Expedition-Based |
Green Corps |
Can integrate with curriculum;
challenges values; cost-efficient; community service |
Limited availability; limited research
evidence |
|
Overseas
Expedition-Based |
Antipodeans (Australia) |
Cultural challenge; involves teachers |
Costly; Limited research evidence |
|
Service-based |
Student visits to retirement villages |
Integrates with community; challenges
values and social skills; cost-efficient; school-based, many
opportunities; involves teachers |
Limited research evidence; extra
demands on teachers |
|
Specialist Teacher(s) |
Outdoor Education Group (Australia) |
Integrates program with school
curriculum; involves school commitment/vision; trained teachers
available |
Limited research evidence |
|
Specialist Resources(s) |
Ropes Challenge Course; Yacht |
Onsite access; integration with
curriculum; involves school commitment/vision |
Limited research evidence |
|
Extended Stay Outdoor Education
Programs |
Timbertop; Glengarry |
Integration with curriculum; lengthy
experience; intact student cohort |
Limited research evidence;
Moderate-high expense; Major capital investment |
|
Ongoing, extra-curricular |
Duke of Edinburgh Award;
Scouts/Guides |
Ongoing, personal development focus,
cost-efficient, targets multiple domains, adaptable to different
students’ needs; involves teachers |
Extra demands on students and teachers;
Limited research evidence |
|
Urban-based Adventure Education |
New York Outward Bound Centre (USA) |
Easy access to urban environment;
integrates with community; cost-efficient |
Limited research evidence |
|
Indoor & Mobile Experiential Challenge |
Project Adventure |
Flexibility; on-site; access to
different types of experiences; aseasonal; no capital investment |
Limited availability; limited research
evidence; not well known |
|
Drama-based Experiential Challenge |
Intertouch (Outward Bound Czech
Republic) |
Flexibility; adaptable to different
learning styles; on- or off-school site; creativity-based challenge |
Limited availability; limited research
evidence; not well known |
|
Spiritual/Religious |
Retreats; Church camps |
Focus on personal/spiritual
development; involves teachers and possibly family; relatively low
cost |
Not all adolescents are receptive;
limited research evidence |
|
Expeditionary Learning |
Expeditionary Learning Outward Bound
(USA) |
Full integration of curriculum with
adventure-based learning principles; involves teachers |
Limited availability; limited research
evidence; not well known; major commitment |